Burundi: 2022 Article IV Consultation-Press Release; Staff Report; and Statement by the Executive Director for Burundi
Author:
International Monetary Fund. African Dept.
Search for other papers by International Monetary Fund. African Dept. in
Current site
Google Scholar
PubMed
Close

1. Burundi is a post-conflict country with deep-rooted fragility (Selected Issues Paper, SIP). The country fell into a political and security crisis following late President Nkurunziza’s decision to run for a third term in 2015. Multidimensional fragility persists, with low capacity, sporadic violence, weak judicial and governance systems, high poverty and inequality, and vulnerability to natural disasters. Burundi’s 2018–27 development plan (Plan National de Dẻveloppement, PND), aims to address key weaknesses through export diversification, infrastructure development, improved access to social safety nets and public services, and better governance. President Ndayishimiye, representing the incumbent ruling party, won the May 2020 elections, succeeding Mr. Nkurunziza who passed away in June 2020, and took steps to reengage with the international community. Amid significant security improvements, the U.N. Security Council ended mandatory reporting on Burundi in 2020, the U.S. lifted in November 2021 the sanctions it imposed in 2015, and the E.U. removed sanctions under Article 96 of the EU-ACP partnership agreement in February 2022.

Abstract

1. Burundi is a post-conflict country with deep-rooted fragility (Selected Issues Paper, SIP). The country fell into a political and security crisis following late President Nkurunziza’s decision to run for a third term in 2015. Multidimensional fragility persists, with low capacity, sporadic violence, weak judicial and governance systems, high poverty and inequality, and vulnerability to natural disasters. Burundi’s 2018–27 development plan (Plan National de Dẻveloppement, PND), aims to address key weaknesses through export diversification, infrastructure development, improved access to social safety nets and public services, and better governance. President Ndayishimiye, representing the incumbent ruling party, won the May 2020 elections, succeeding Mr. Nkurunziza who passed away in June 2020, and took steps to reengage with the international community. Amid significant security improvements, the U.N. Security Council ended mandatory reporting on Burundi in 2020, the U.S. lifted in November 2021 the sanctions it imposed in 2015, and the E.U. removed sanctions under Article 96 of the EU-ACP partnership agreement in February 2022.

Context

1. Burundi is a post-conflict country with deep-rooted fragility (Selected Issues Paper, SIP). The country fell into a political and security crisis following late President Nkurunziza’s decision to run for a third term in 2015. Multidimensional fragility persists, with low capacity, sporadic violence, weak judicial and governance systems, high poverty and inequality, and vulnerability to natural disasters. Burundi’s 2018–27 development plan (Plan National de Dẻveloppement, PND), aims to address key weaknesses through export diversification, infrastructure development, improved access to social safety nets and public services, and better governance. President Ndayishimiye, representing the incumbent ruling party, won the May 2020 elections, succeeding Mr. Nkurunziza who passed away in June 2020, and took steps to reengage with the international community. Amid significant security improvements, the U.N. Security Council ended mandatory reporting on Burundi in 2020, the U.S. lifted in November 2021 the sanctions it imposed in 2015, and the E.U. removed sanctions under Article 96 of the EU-ACP partnership agreement in February 2022.

2. Burundi’s economy had been resilient prior to the COVID-19 pandemic (Figures 16). Growth recovered to 1.8 percent in 2019 and inflation averaged -0.7 percent owing to abundant crop (SIP). The current account (CA) deficit was stable, at 11.6 percent of GDP, supported by gold exports, remittances, and official transfers. The fiscal deficit remained large, at 6.2 percent of GDP in 2018/19, although revenue collection had been robust. Foreign exchange (FX) reserves were anemic (1.3 months of imports at end-2019) and a large parallel exchange rate (ER) market premium persisted (SIP).

Figure 1.
Figure 1.

Burundi: Recent Developments, 2014–22

Citation: IMF Staff Country Reports 2022, 257; 10.5089/9798400219122.002.A001

Sources: Burundi authorities and IMF staff estimates and projections.
Figure 2.
Figure 2.

Burundi: Recent Monetary Developments, 2011–22

Citation: IMF Staff Country Reports 2022, 257; 10.5089/9798400219122.002.A001

Sources: Burundi authorities and IMF staff estimates and projections.
Figure 3.
Figure 3.

Burundi: Fiscal Developments, 2014–211

Citation: IMF Staff Country Reports 2022, 257; 10.5089/9798400219122.002.A001

Sources: Burundi authorities and IMF staff estimates and calculations.1 Fiscal year values (July-June) starting in 2019 (i.e. 2019 is FY 2018/19). Includes COVID-related fiscal measures starting in FY 2020/21
Figure 4.
Figure 4.

Burundi: Banking Sector Key Indicators and Trends, 2011–21

Citation: IMF Staff Country Reports 2022, 257; 10.5089/9798400219122.002.A001

Sources: Banque de la Republique du Burundi and the World Bank.
Figure 5.
Figure 5.

Burundi: Growth Developments, 2000–26

Citation: IMF Staff Country Reports 2022, 257; 10.5089/9798400219122.002.A001

Sources: World Development Indicators; Country Policy and Institutional Assessment Report 2020; Burundi authorities; IMF WEO; and IMF staff calculations and projections.
Figure 6.
Figure 6.

Burundi: Selected Social Indicators, 2010–20

Citation: IMF Staff Country Reports 2022, 257; 10.5089/9798400219122.002.A001

Sources: World Bank WDI; Burundi authorities; and IMF staff estimates.

3. The economic recovery was disrupted by the pandemic, while spillovers from the war in Ukraine pose headwinds to growth. The authorities prepared a response plan to limit the COVID-19 spread and cushion its macroeconomic and social impact (Annex I). The plan, which was costed at US$150 million, included a sanitary plan of US$ 58 million (1.8 percent of GDP) and infrastructure investment to improve public health capacity and access. The pandemic led to a slowdown in growth to 0.3 percent in 2020, despite subdued contagion (0.3 percent of the population as of June 7, 2022), including during the Omicron wave. Vaccination started in October 2021 but remains limited (less than one percent of the population). The war in Ukraine is expected to further weigh on the recovery.

4. The 2022 Article IV Consultation seals Burundi’s full reengagement with the Fund since the last Article IV in 2014. Burundi benefited from five tranches of debt relief under the Catastrophe Containment and Relief Trust (CCRT, SDR 17.96 million) starting in 2020, the general SDR allocation of August 2021 (SDR 147.6 million or 6.3 percent of GDP), and a disbursement under the Rapid Credit Facility (RCF, SDR 53.9 million or 2.3 percent of GDP) in October 2021.

Recent Macroeconomic Developments

5. Inward spillovers from the war in Ukraine are sizeable, with a commensurate government response (Text Table 1). Disruptions to supply chains, including to Ukraine’s ability to exports, sanctions against Russia and Belarus, and the hoarding behavior of major food producers deteriorated Burundi’s terms of trade. Food and fuel imports prices soared, increasing Burundi’s import bill, and compounding the effects of pre-existing FX shortages, which increased domestic fuel rationing and transportation disruptions.1 Moreover, while Japan and Russia announced donations in-kind to help stem import pressures, they have not materialized yet. Export prices dropped, including tea prices (-12 percent in 2022) and coffee prices somewhat (-1 percent), reducing Burundi’s export proceeds. Gold prices have increased, though slightly (+1.1 percent in 2022), cushioning the terms of trade deterioration. The spillovers will be long-lived as prices are not expected to return to pre-war projections in the medium term.

Text Table 1.

Burundi: Mitigating Measures

article image

6. Burundi’s economy is recovering although it grapples with a weak external position.

  • Growth and Inflation. Output growth is estimated to have rebounded to 3.1 percent in 2021 mainly driven by a recovery in services, thanks to easing travel and border restrictions. Recent agricultural reforms, including better quality crops and timely availability of inputs, have started to bear fruit although floods and landslides hampered agricultural production. The secondary sector slowed down as major mining companies ceased production pending the renegotiation of their contracts. Inflation averaged 8.3 percent in 2021 (7.3 percent in 2020), driven by rising food prices including wheat flour prices (+25 percent in December 2021). Inflationary pressures are further compounded by spillovers from the war in Ukraine —y/y inflation stood at 11.9 percent in May 2022.

  • External sector. The CA deficit widened to 13.4 percent of GDP in 2021 (10.2 percent in 2020), mainly due to the recovery in fuel and food imports. Lower oil prices in early 2021, lower imported volume of petroleum products owing to the limited FX availability, and increasing workers’ remittances2 helped contain the CA deficit. Exports receded in 2021 mainly owing to the drop in mining production. The capital and financial accounts improved thanks to IMF flows, supporting an FX reserves buildup to 2.2 months of imports at end-2021 (0.6 month in March 2021). In 2022H1, the authorities exchanged a total of SDR 57 million (US$ 80 million) of their SDR allocation for U.S. dollars to cope with the spillovers from the war in Ukraine. Burundi’s external position for 2021 is substantially weaker than implied by fundamentals and desirable policies. The external sector assessment (ESA, Annex II) reveals a significant misalignment of the real effective ER of 68.6 percent (Text Table 2). The parallel ER market premium stood at 62.5 percent at mid-June 2022.3

  • Monetary and financial sectors. Nonperforming loans (NPLs) stood at 4.1 percent at end-September 2021. However, this figure is flattered by regulatory forbearance measures. Indeed, the number of loans that have been restructured is large (one third of loans in commerce). Private credit growth (44.8 percent at end-2021)4 has been supported by the Banque de la République du Burundi (BRB)’s direct lending, government guarantees to para-public projects, and favorable refinancing terms (para. 32). Two new banks were created to target the youth and women.

uA001fig01

Burundi: Real GDP Growth Projections and Sector Contributions, 2021

Citation: IMF Staff Country Reports 2022, 257; 10.5089/9798400219122.002.A001

Sources: IMF staff projections.
Text Table 2.

Burundi: EBA-Lite Model Estimates, 2021

(Percent of GDP)

article image

Based on the EBA-lite 3.0 methodology

Additional cyclical adjustment to account for the temporary impact of the pandemic onremittances (0,1 percent of GDP).

Cyclically adjusted, including multilateral consistency adjustments.

7. The fiscal deficit is projected to narrow to 5 percent of GDP in 2021/22 (July-June) from 7.8 percent in 2020/21, thanks to strong revenue collection:

  • Revenue collection is projected at 18.8 percent of GDP in 2021/22 (18.5 percent in 2020/21). Overperformance (1.6 percent of GDP higher than budget projections), reflects new revenue measures (Text Table 3, para. 16, and SIP) and strong VAT and non-tax revenue collection, which compensated a shortfall from petroleum imports revenue in 2021Q4. Vaccine donations are expected to boost grants.

  • Spending is projected at 28.8 percent of GDP (24.2 percent of GDP in the budget). While the budget includes pandemic-related spending of 1 percent of GDP (excluding vaccines). Additional spending needs include vaccines and associated costs (1.5 percent of GDP)5 and other spending (3.2 percent of GDP), mainly reflecting underbudgeted interest payments and incurred outlays in 2021H2.6 Under-execution of investment (-0.3 percent of GDP) will help contain the deficit.

  • The fiscal deficit would be financed with government securities issuances, central bank on-lending to the government of the accessed SDR allocation (para. 6), and external financing.

Text Table 3.

Burundi: Impact of Revenue Measures

(Percent of GDP)

article image
Sources: Burundi authorities and IMF staff estimates and projections

Outlook and Risks

8. Growth is expected to recover somewhat in 2022 and strengthen over the medium term (Text Table 4, Figure 5). It is projected to increase to 3.3 percent in 2022, and progressively stabilize at around 4.6 percent over the medium term, supported by stronger terms of trade, higher agricultural and mining production,7 buoyant services activities, and capital projects. Several World Bank and AfDB projects8 are underway and should be finalized during 2022–25, thus boosting investment and adding to the economy’s productive capacity. These growth drivers are consistent with the PND. In addition to ongoing structural reforms (SIP), the planned use of the SDR allocation to scale up public investment and the less tight import restrictions will support GDP growth and mitigate the effects of the projected fiscal consolidation. The outlook is contingent on a pickup in vaccinations, durable political stability, and reengagement with the international community, with limited though increasing external financing flows.9 Growth will also be supported by addressing governance and corruption vulnerabilities.

Text Table 4.

Burundi: Key Macroeconomic Indicators under the Baseline, 2020–27

article image
Sources: Burundi authorities; and IMF staff estimates and projections.

A statistical adjustment (15 percent) was applied to credit growth to account for the reclassification of a bank—the Urban Housing Promotion Fund became the Burundi Housing Bank in 2021 and is now covered in the monetary survey.

Fiscal year values (July-June) starting in 2019 (i.e. 2019 is FY 2018/19). Includes the grant for the IMF debt service falling due from October 16, 2021 to April 13, 2022, which is subject to the availability of resources under the CCRT.

9. Inflation is projected to rise to 11 percent in 2022 and recede afterwards. With the share of tradable goods in the CPI estimated at 42 percent, inflation pressures are high (Text Table 5)—inflation was projected at 5.5 percent pre-war. The authorities raised domestic pump prices twice in 2022Q1 (20 percent in total) and transportation fees (30 percent). Beyond 2023, inflation is projected to remain contained under the authorities’ current policies focused on boosting, agricultural production, imports substitution policies, price regulations, and FX allocation policy (para. 27).10 The BRB’s regulatory initiatives are likely to continue boosting private sector credit in the medium term (para. 32).

Text Table 5.

Burundi: CPI Composition and Contribution to Inflation

article image
Source: ISTEEBU and IMF staff calculations

Includes bread, cereal, sea fruit, oil and grease, coffee, tea, and some soda.

10. External imbalances are projected to persist. The CA deficit would widen significantly in 2022 to 14.4 percent of GDP, partly driven by: (i) deteriorating terms of trade; (ii) vaccines and other COVID-19 related imports; and (iii) easing of import restrictions as the RCF disbursement and SDR allocation improved FX availability. Export volumes would recover, under the impulse of the end of mining contract negotiations and a vibrant food industry. Beyond 2022, the CA deficit would narrow as terms of trade improve slightly and current transfers strengthen. The capital and financial account dynamics reflect mainly donor inflows11—projections of official inflows are however conservative compared to the prospects from Burundi’s reengagement with the international community, and they account for implementation capacity (para. 12). In the absence of ER and FX market reforms, FX reserves would drop to 2.1 months of imports in 2022, partly owing to the import content of investment projects, and further decrease afterwards in the absence of significant inflows.

11. Burundi is at high risk of external and overall debt distress; and debt is assessed as sustainable contingent on fiscal adjustment, and robust export and growth—debt sustainability analysis (DSA). Public debt stood at 66.6 percent of GDP at end-2021 with key risks stemming from the large stock of domestic debt and liquidity constraints to service external liabilities. Risks to external debt service are mitigated by strong and resilient remittances and prospects of higher FX inflows, including through increased grants and concessional loans. Staff’s assessment of debt sustainability is subject to significant risks, including uncertainties around domestic policies and the external environment. Existing domestic and external imbalances, including the large parallel ER market premium, heighten risks to debt sustainability. Long delays in exchange rate reform could further widen the ER market premium and amplify existing imbalances. Delays in fiscal consolidation, slow implementation of structural reforms, persistent information gap on arrears, and lingering effects of the COVID-19 pandemic or war in Ukraine would heighten debt vulnerabilities as well. A large ER depreciation would worsen debt vulnerabilities in the near term, while being beneficial after the initial shock as external debt is limited.

uA001fig02

Burundi: Debts Sustainability Analysis Indicators

Citation: IMF Staff Country Reports 2022, 257; 10.5089/9798400219122.002.A001

1/ The most extreme stress test is the test that yields the highest ratio on or before 2032Sources: IMF staff calculations

12. Both upside and downside risks to the outlook are significant (Risk Assessment Matrix, Annex III).

  • Upside risks. Recently announced in-kind grants from Japan (fuel) and Russia (fuel, fertilizers, medicines, and health equipment) and an expected equity disbursement from a newly signed mining contract (nickel)12 would significantly strengthen the BOP and support growth (para. 6). Higher yield of recent revenue measures (para. 16) would increase fiscal space and may improve debt dynamics. Upside potential also includes potentially larger-than-projected external financing from the international community, reflecting recent lifting of U.S. and E.U. sanctions—grants averaged 17.7 percent of GDP per year during 2010–14 compared to 8.6 percent assumed in the baseline medium-term projections. Higher grants would increase fiscal space for public investment and reserve coverage, and thus ease FX access limitations and import rationing, alleviating two significant impediments to growth. Highly concessional long-term external financing would substitute for more expensive domestic financing, reducing borrowing cost and debt vulnerabilities. This Article IV consultation could help boost donor confidence and lay the foundation for a more ambitious reform agenda, including further flexibility in ER management,13 that would enhance competitiveness and boost growth.

  • Downside risks pertain to (i) domestic policies, notably delays in implementing the policies that underpin the baseline, natural disasters potentially leading to higher domestic inflation, and a deterioration of the political and security situation and (ii) external uncertainties linked to the end of the pandemic and possible stronger and longer spillovers from the war in Ukraine, as well as de-anchoring of inflation expectations, rising energy and food prices, and weak global demand and investor confidence owing to outbreaks of COVID-19 variants.

Authorities’ Views

13. The authorities broadly agreed with staff’s macroeconomic projections, though they were more optimistic on the growth path, notably owing to the potential impact of ongoing reforms. The authorities acknowledged the higher imported inflation and noted that this impact will be limited because of regulation on fuel prices and the ongoing import substitution policy.

Policy Priorities

14. Discussions focused on macroeconomic policies and CD priorities to (i) create fiscal space to cope with the COVID-19 pandemic and the war in Ukraine and accommodate development spending while being attuned to debt vulnerabilities; (ii) restore external sustainability and strengthen the monetary policy framework while containing inflation; (iii) foster financial stability; and (iv) sustain inclusive growth and reduce fragility, including through fiscal governance reforms.

15. A policy mix that balances priority spending needs and addresses debt and external vulnerabilities is required to weather multi-dimensional challenges. On the one hand, spending pressures are high as (i) further execution of the authorities’ COVID-19 response plan (Annex I) is warranted to contain the spread of new variants, including improving the vaccination rate; (ii) social spending needs are heightened by the effects of the war in Ukraine, including to prevent food insecurity; and (iii) Burundi must cater to its development needs, including increasing priority investment to spur sustainable growth and expand social safety nets (SSN) to reduce population fragility (SIP). On the other hand, a multi-pronged policy rebalancing is inevitable and urgent. Reducing debt vulnerabilities with, inter alia, a better-quality fiscal consolidation path achieved with higher revenue and scaled-up investment and prudent borrowing is a top priority (para. 11. ). Furthermore, it is critical to carefully calibrate exit from accommodative MP and undertake in-depth reforms to rebalance ER policy and the monetary policy (MP) framework, while being attuned to financial sector vulnerabilities, to restore external sustainability.

Creating Fiscal Space for Priority Spending

16. Staff expects the 2022/23 fiscal deficit to widen to 7.4 percent of GDP reflecting predominantly higher capital outlays, although partly offset by a notable improvement in tax revenue and grants (Text Tables 6 and 7). The preliminary budget, which envisages a lower deficit, is being prepared under program budget approach, an accelerated reform timeline supported by CD.

  • Staff projects that revenue would improve by 0.7 percent of GDP to 19.5 percent of GDP, mainly driven by VAT collections, reflecting the full year impact of revenue measures adopted in 2021/22 (para. 7 and Text Table 6) and planned measures (para. 17), although accounting for potential implementation hurdles. International trade taxes will also increase, boosted by higher imports. Project grants would benefit from the lifting of sanctions.

  • Expenditure is projected to rise in 2022/23 to 36.7 percent of GDP, mainly driven by public investments financed by project grants and the SDR allocation, which would fast-track implementation of the authorities’ public investment plan (PIP), including a regional railway project and road, electricity, and health projects. Reduced COVID-19 expenses will contain spending.

  • The deficit should be largely financed by domestic resources, including on-lending of the accessed SDR allocation (para. 26. ), and foreign financing.

Text Table 6.

Burundi: Revenue Measures Implemented with the 2021/22 Budget

article image
Sources: Burundi authorities and IMF staff.
Text Table 7.

Burundi: Fiscal Policy, 2020–231

(Percent of GDP unless otherwise indicated)

article image
Sources: Burundi authorities; and IMF staff estimates and projections.

Overperformance of revenue in FY2021/22 reflects new revenue measures and strong VAT and non-tax revenue collection. Additional spending outlays in FY2D21/22 compared to the budget include vaccines and associated costs (1.5 percent of GDP) and other spending (3.2 percent of GDP), mainly reflecting underbudgeted interest payments and incurred outlays in 2021H2. The higher fiscal deficit would be financed with higher government securities issuances, central bank lending to the government, and eternal financing, inclduing the from the IMF RCF.

Covid spending envisaged in the FY2021/22 budget (BIF 70.4 billion or 1 percent of GDP) is not itemized in the budget but is included in some current and investment spending lines such as transfers to hospitals,

Staff projects that the central bank will on-lend in local currency to the government the equivalent of half of the SDR allocation in FV2022/23 (2.6 percent of GDP) and the remainder in FV2023/24 and FV2024/25.

17. The plan to adopt additional revenue measures in the 2022/23 budget is welcome. Those include (i) an excise tax on cigarettes; and (ii) lump sum levies on some products (e.g., drinks).

18. While efforts for domestic revenue mobilization (DRM) and boosting investment are critical, staff recommended to accommodate sufficient COVID-related and social spending in FY2022/23. Given economic scarring risks and low vaccination rates, accommodating COVID-related spending remains important. Expanding the SSN and the funding of existing social programs (SIP) is also critical to help the vulnerable populations cope with the twin shocks—inflationary pressures could entrench living standards losses triggered by the pandemic.

19. Staff advised that the expected fiscal space generated by higher revenues and contained COVID-19 expenditure be partly used for appropriately targeted social programs (SIP) and measures to mitigate the adverse impact of revenue measures. The authorities have improved SSNs in recent years, including providing: (i) free primary education; (ii) an education support fund; (iii) free health care for children under five and women giving birth; and (iv) free care and selected medication. They also reviewed the institutional, legal, and regulatory framework for social protection. The 2021/22 budget expanded social programs targeted at women, the youth, people with disabilities, and natural disaster victims. This will also be essential to shield the vulnerable from the possible adverse impact of some revenue measures (especially those on basic goods and the informal sector) and to foster social cohesion. Efficient targeting will be required to ensure sustainability.

20. Recent spending rationalization and PFM measures are expected to improve efficiency. The 2020/21 and 2021/22 budget laws (i) froze hiring in all public sectors, except defense and security, education, health, and the revenue administration starting July 1, 2021; (ii) adopted a “fair wage policy” to reduce wage disparities in the public sector by using a job classification and rating system, stabilize the wage bill, and improve its predictability;14 and (iii) introduced multi-year procurement and payment plans to strengthen investment management.

21. Nonetheless, further gains could be reaped by streamlining tax expenditures. Tax expenditures were much higher than the budgeted envelope in 2020/21 (Text Table 8), mainly driven by government and automatic exemptions for donor and NGO activities. Exemptions for private investors were also large. Staff recommended documenting tax expenditures in budget execution reports and assessing their efficiency.

Text Table 8.

Burundi: Composition of Tax Expenditures

(Percent of GDP)

article image
Sources: Burundi authorities

Including agricultural inputs and veterinary products

22. Under current policies, gradual fiscal consolidation over the medium term would put the public debt ratio on a downward trajectory. Revenue collection would modestly strengthen, thanks to continued DRM efforts. Spending would gradually decline with investment receding after the scaling-up of 2022/23 and 2023/24, rationalization measures (para. 20), and unwinding COVID-19 related spending. The fiscal deficit would gradually narrow to about 2 percent of GDP, despite conservative donor inflows (para. 10 and para. 12), and public debt would decline to about 55 percent of GDP.

23. Staff recommended a more ambitious medium-term fiscal consolidation, supported by quality scaling-up of DRM, investment, and SSNs to decisively reduce debt vulnerabilities and support policy recalibration. Stronger fiscal consolidation efforts are needed to bring the PV of debt-to-GDP ratio closer to its indicative benchmark of 35 percent of GDP and strengthen public debt sustainability (DSA). To this end, staff recommended:

  • Stronger DRM, including by improving compliance with further digitalization and widening the tax base, accelerating the implementation of new measures (Text Table 9), and creating a unique taxpayer identification number to facilitate controls. The authorities also plan to strengthen dividend collection from public enterprises and excise taxes. An upcoming diagnostic CD mission (Fall 2022) will help design a medium-term revenue strategy. However, considerations must be given to striking a balance between DRM and possible social costs.

  • Spending rationalization and recalibration by continuing to shift the spending mix15 towards investment—public investment remains below ratios in peer countries. A gradual shift would ensure efficient planning and selection of mature high-return projects. Staff recommended CD on public investment management. Staff reiterated the recommendation made at the RCF disbursement stage that, owing to external vulnerabilities, the SDR allocation should be primarily devoted to bolstering FX reserves coverage.

Text Table 9.

Burundi. Revenue Measures Envisaged in the 2021/22 Budget and not yet Implemented

article image
Sources: Burundi authorities and IMF staff.
uA001fig03

Burundi: Public Investment in Burundi and Peer Countries, 2010–26

(Percent of GDP)

Citation: IMF Staff Country Reports 2022, 257; 10.5089/9798400219122.002.A001

Sources: IMF WEO and IMF staff projections and calculations

Authorities’ Views

24. The authorities reiterated their commitment to DRM and prudent borrowing to create space for investment while ensuring debt sustainability. They welcomed CD offers and noted that efficient planning will help account for absorptive capacity. They saw digitalization as having major potential to increase VAT collections through electronic billing and digital payment systems and that they aim to increase mining revenues through the ongoing mining sector reform. The authorities underscored efforts to further widen the tax base by capturing activities in the informal sector and land transactions and ownership. They argued that tax exemptions are mainly linked to donor and international rules.

25. The authorities noted that their spending policies are guided by Burundi’s PND. They view the new “fair wage policy” as an angular reform, which will reduce salary inequities in the public service and boost public service efficiency. They agreed with the need to protect social spending and highlighted that their ability to scale up social programs beyond recent reforms is constrained by financing. They flagged that their ambitious PIP would boost economic growth, hence reducing debt vulnerabilities and attracting foreign investment and FX inflows. They explained that expediting the implementation of program budgeting was important to better align public spending with government objectives.

Enroute for Exchange Rate Unification

Ensuring External Sustainability

26. Burundi’s external imbalances are large, although the SDR allocation provided a much-needed relief. Vulnerabilities include a weak external position, large CA deficit, FX reserves below adequacy levels, and significant REER misalignment (para. 6 and para. 10). While the SDR allocation helped, the authorities plan to use it to finance investment. Staff projects on-lending of half of the SDR allocation in 2022/23 (2.6 percent of GDP) and the remainder in 2023/24 and 2024/25.

27. The BRB has undertaken several measures to manage FX reserves (SIP). Exporters are required to surrender to the BRB all exports proceeds at the official ER. The BRB is the sole seller in the FX interbank market. FX allocations to commercial banks are directed to imports deemed priority, including medicines, fuel, and investment-related imports. FX allocation decisions (on importers, amount, and timing) also account for the need to contain inflation. There is anecdotal evidence of uneven FX allocation across banks, which increases the structural bottleneck.

28. Staff stressed that external policy recalibration is essential to ensure external sustainability, including unification of the official and parallel ER as early as possible and rebuilding FX buffers. There are two possible approaches (Text Table 10):

  • i. A gradual adjustment within a target period. The official ER would gradually decrease, following a rule or a discretionary path until it reaches its equilibrium level, preferably within a short period. This approach bears the advantage of allowing a smoother adjustment of economic actors, including the financial sector. A gradual approach would be costly in terms of FX reserves and may delay gains from removing FX distortions. It is nonetheless feasible as the SDR allocation and surrender requirements have reinforced FX buffers.

  • ii. An immediate large adjustment (“instant unification”). The official ER would instantly depreciate to a level that would alleviate the FX market distortions, determined based on the real effective ER misalignment and the parallel ER market premium. This approach would highly boost investor confidence.

Text Table 10.

Burundi: Approaches to Exchange Rate Unification

article image

29. While the choice will be guided by practical considerations, including the political economy, other key policy decisions must be made in conjunction with the ER unification. The approach to ER unification should account for FX reserves coverage, the global environment, and associated financial sector risks. Clear supportive communication would also be important. Country experiences suggest that the impact on inflation is usually limited where the size of the parallel ER market is large; however, this has to be ascertained for Burundi. Nonetheless, both approaches to ER unification bear risks that may require tighter monetary policy (MP) and financial regulation and supervision, in addition to prudent external debt management. The impact on financial sector stability will likely be limited as currency mismatches appear limited. Other policy decisions include a post-unification ER policy, possibly a managed float, an efficient MP framework, as well as fiscal consolidation and plans to exit monetary financing.

Authorities’ Views

30. The authorities reiterated their commitment to maintaining macroeconomic stability, including external and debt sustainability. They acknowledged the large parallel ER market premium and external imbalances and stressed the need to carefully design any reform agenda to Burundi’s characteristics. They cautioned against the potential inflationary impact of a sharp ER depreciation, which would predominantly affect the vulnerable population. The authorities appreciated the ongoing discussions on (i) cross-country experiences on ER unification and reforms; (ii) options of post-unification ER regimes and MP framework and instruments; (iii) fiscal and monetary policy coordination; and potential socio-economic implications and look forward to the upcoming CD mission. The authorities agreed that financial stability risks are muted. They acknowledged the need for a multi-pronged policy adjustment and reminded that the large ER parallel market premium was triggered by the sudden drop in donor support during the crisis. They stressed that ER unification would be facilitated by higher donor support. The authorities stressed their commitment to agree with staff on a policy reform roadmap, which will guide their actions in implementing the ER reform in the medium term, while accounting for the specificities of Burundi’s economy as well as the economic and socio-political implications of the reform.

Monetary Policy Challenges and Framework

31. BRB’s MP framework is elaborate, albeit in need of improvement. The overarching objective of the MP is price stability, which is achieved through quantitative targeting of monetary aggregates and other instruments (SIP). Statutory advances were officially discontinued in 2017, although indirect monetary financing has surged since the pandemic. The budget is mainly financed through government securities. The interbank market functions relatively well, with little segmentation but low transaction volume. The efficiency of MP transmission and its impact on inflation management is limited.

32. The BRB supported banks’ liquidity during the pandemic and encouraged long-term loans to priority sectors using its regular instruments and quasi-fiscal tools, with however unintended effects. Measures included (i) increasing liquidity provisions (+16 percent in 2020 compared to 2019); (ii) creating a refinancing window that provides to banks long-term liquidity (5 years, renewable once) at subsidized interest rate (2 percent), which banks lend to priority sectors at a maximum rate of 8 percent and maturity of up to 10 years; (iii) extending direct and indirect loans to the Treasury to support the production of coffee, fertilizer, and maize; (iv) relaxing loan restructuring provisions to allow a fourth restructuring. These measures have been efficient in supporting banks’ health and boosting credit. However, the long-term refinancing window has decreased the buoyancy of the regular 7-day refinancing window. The efficiency of the overnight interest rate remains limited.

33. Staff stressed that considering ongoing inflationary pressures and rapid credit growth, the BRB should prepare to wind down the long-term refinancing window and carefully calibrate the exit from other measures. The sharp surge in inflation has raised challenges for MP and the “fair wage policy” is likely to raise public sector wages in the near term. MP challenges are further compounded by the fact that inflation is mostly driven by volatile supply factors, which might limit the efficacy of MP in stabilizing prices. Therefore, cautious forward-looking monetary policy making is warranted. Inflationary risks are however mitigated by regulated prices and limited risks of wage-price spirals—the “fair wage policy” will help contain pressures and private sector wages are unlikely to catch up as informal jobs are predominant. Timely signaling should be given to the market before unwinding the new refinancing window. Staff however acknowledges the positive impact of MP measures on credit growth and the opportunity costs of prematurely deferring accommodative monetary policy, as fiscal space is limited.

34. A MP framework geared towards using interest rates would support the plans for ER unification, while ensuring a transition towards the Eastern African Community (EAC) directive to adopt inflation targeting (IT) in the future. Staff advised against direct private sector financing and creating new instruments to finance the economy in the future and recommended reducing monetary financing, which will help prepare for ER unification (para. 28 and para. 29). Staff advocated strengthening the efficiency of the MP framework’s regular instruments, including interest rates transmission, deepening the interbank market, and designing an efficient communication framework, building on upcoming CD to strengthen domestic and FX-related liquidity forecasting and macro-modeling.

Authorities’ Views

35. The authorities concurred with staff on the need to modernize the MP framework and strengthen the interest rate link. They emphasize that the new window has supported the banking sector and helped provide credit to previously underserved sectors (agriculture and industry), which was key in the economy’s resilience to the pandemic. The authorities acknowledged that it is tricky to calibrate the timing to unwind MP support and highlighted that they used to have regular communications to the public and will consider revamping their communication strategy. They noted that technical preparations to transition to an IT framework as per the EAC’s directives are advanced.

Fostering Financial Sector Stability

36. While the banking sector is diversified and appears healthy, caution is advised. There are 14 commercial banks with total assets amounting to 60 percent of GDP and credit to the private sector exceeding 20 percent of GDP. Vulnerabilities seem subdued with capital ratios of around 20 percent, higher than the regulatory requirement and the net open FX positions are negligible (Figure 4 and SIP). Although stable, NPLs are concentrated in certain sectors, including trade (27.1 percent), real estate (15.7 percent), and transportation (12.8 percent) and their low level is partly due to write-offs and increased loan restructurings.16 Staff advised a forward-looking approach to supervision to detect emerging tensions.

Authorities’ Views

37. The authorities look forward to continued CD to improve regulatory and supervisory frameworks. They agreed with the importance of strengthening supervisory frameworks and related financial stability assessments and underscored that they do not foresee major financial stability issues related to ER unification and FX market liberalization.

Unlocking Sustainable Inclusive Growth

38. Burundi’s fragility is high. Burundi’s average CPIA score was 2.9 in 2019, well below the 3.2 threshold for fragility, and its poverty rate stood at 85 percent in 2020. The country faces multidimensional fragility (SIP), including regarding social inclusion and equity. The pandemic has worsened social outcomes, notably poverty, inequality, employment, and gender issues.

39. Competitiveness is challenged (SIP). The country ranks low on competitiveness indicators, particularly these related to utility infrastructure such as electricity access and exposure to unsafe drinking water. Other constraints include low digitalization and productivity, limited competition owing to dominant SOEs, lack of collateral and credit bureaus, and skill mismatches. Climate shocks, including droughts and floods, often led to growth swings. A growth accounting decomposition shows that economic growth has been mainly driven by higher capital and labor, while negative productivity growth weighed on growth, especially in 2015 and 2016. Reforms to enhance human capital, improve health conditions, as well as support physical capital accumulation and enhance productivity would help promote private sector development and growth.

40. Boosting growth will also require further enhancing governance and tackling corruption. Reflecting the early stages of reengagement and related information gaps on Burundi’s broad governance framework, staff presented the Fund’s 2018 Enhanced Governance Framework and offered CD for a Governance Diagnostic Assessment.

41. Work on commitments on the transparency and audit of spending related to COVID-19 and the SDR allocation, taken under the CCRT and RCF disbursement, is ongoing.

  • The authorities accelerated the preparation of the budget review laws (Loi de Règlements) for 2016 onwards to meet the CCRT’s commitment to produce the 2020/21 report—the deadline of March 2022 was only slightly passed. The RCF and SDR allocation-related spending will concomitantly be audited in the context of the related budget review laws.

  • The authorities prepared in mid-August 2021 the first COVID-19 spending report, covering spending up to August 10, 2021—RCF’s commitment to preparing, starting end-December 2021, bi-annual reports on COVID-19 spending audited by the Court of Auditors (Cour des Comptes, SIP) and published on the ministry’s website within three months of the end of each semester. The audit report has been delayed by the backlog of budget execution reports.

  • The authorities committed to collecting information on the ultimate beneficial ownership (BO) of companies that were awarded COVID-related contracts starting in end-December 2021. The 2018 procurement law requires publishing procurement plans by end-February of each year and auctioning of public contracts (SIP); however, BO information is not being collected. Staff discussed the possibility of targeted legal drafting assistance on secondary legislation to enhance transparency and accountability of public procurement (Financial Action Task Force recommendation). Burundi’s AML/CFT framework also needs to be aligned with international standards and its newly setup financial intelligence unit should be made fully operational. Staff advises fast implementation of the steps required for full membership in the Eastern and Southern Africa Anti-Money Laundering Group (ESAAMLG)—a FATF-style regional body. An update of the 2012 PEFA assessment is planned in 2022.

Authorities’ Views

42. The authorities agreed that boosting economic growth will require ambitious structural reforms and rigorous project implementation. They noted that climate change poses a challenge to growth in Burundi and emphasized that the two new banks for the youth and women will be useful in that regard.

43. The authorities noted that the audit of COVID-19 spending is ongoing and reiterated their commitment to collect information on ultimate BO of COVID-related contracts. The first report on COVID operations was transmitted to the Court of Auditors on August 13, 2021, covering spending from December 24, 2020, to August 10, 2021 (0.4 percent of GDP). Its audit started in April due to the backlog of audits of budget review laws--this has been resolved and the Court of Auditors published the audit reports covering 2016–2021. The authorities noted that the audit of the budget review law for 2020/21 has also reviewed concurrent COVID-related spending. The authorities noted that in the past, they were able to identify the ultimate BO of some companies awarded government contracts. The changes in the regulatory framework would facilitate the automatic collection of BO information.

Other Issues

44. Article VIII. Since the 2014 Article IV consultation, the authorities have introduced important changes to the FX system. Staff discussed with the authorities measures that could possibly constitute exchange restrictions and multiple currency practices (MCPs, see Informational Annex, IA) inconsistent with Article VIII, sections 2(a), 3, and 4. This includes a surrender requirement, prioritization of FX allocation, and limits on FX availability for certain transactions. Staff will collect further information, mainly from market participants to conduct further assessment.

45. Data adequacy and capacity development. Data is assessed broadly adequate for surveillance, with notable improvements since 2014 supported by CD, including regarding the accuracy, timeliness, and coverage of data. Notably, BOP data were broadened, and staff’s baseline macroframework reflects official national accounts data from 2020 (Annex V and IA). The authorities have initiated steps towards adopting e-GDDS standards. An CD strategy was elaborated and discussed with the authorities—key priorities include DRM, PFM, monetary and ER policy, and statistics (including GDP rebasing).

46. Other. An updated safeguards assessment is ongoing (IA)—the first one since 2012.

Staff Appraisal

47. Burundi’s economy is striving to rebound from three shocks: the 2015 political and security crisis, the COVID-19 health shock, and the war in Ukraine. Although the recovery from the political crisis was halted, the economy has shown resilience to the pandemic with output growth remaining positive and accelerating in 2021. The authorities’ COVID-19 response plan helped contain the virus spread, though vaccination remains low.

48. Spillovers of the war in Ukraine are compounding the effects of the pandemic and are threatening the nascent economic recovery. Spillovers are mainly linked to trade with disruptions to supply chains, including to Ukraine’s ability to exports, sanctions against Russia and Belarus, and the hoarding behavior of major food producers, raising food and fuel imports prices. Lower export prices weigh on export receipts. The outlook for 2022 is positive with growth set to increase only modestly to 3.3 percent and inflation to reach 11 percent. Deteriorating terms of trade have put pressure on below-adequacy FX reserves, increasing fuel shortages and transportation disruptions. Nevertheless, both positive and downside risks are significant, with on the upside recent announcements of grants and a new mining contract and prospects of higher donor funding reflecting the lifting of all sanctions linked to the 2015 political and security crisis.

49. A policy mix recalibration is needed to address Burundi’s debt vulnerabilities and external imbalances. With public debt at 66.5 percent of GDP at end-2021 and expected to decrease gradually over the medium term, Burundi’s debt is sustainable with high risk of debt distress. The external position is weak with FX reserve coverage at 2.2 months of imports at end-2021 and projected to further weaken, and there is a large parallel ER market premium. A recalibrated fiscal, exchange rate, monetary, and financial policy mix is necessary to address the vulnerabilities and face the effects of the ongoing twin shocks.

50. An ambitious fiscal consolidation underpinned by DRM is critical to address debt vulnerabilities while protecting priority COVID-related, social, and investment spending. Staff welcome the authorities’ decision to allow domestic price adjustments, which limited the impact of the shock on subsidies and the budget. Staff also welcome the near-term budget focus on health, social, and infrastructure spending. However, going forward, it is critical to further bolster DRM including with further digitalization, tax base widening, and improvements in compliance. Further shifting the spending mix towards investment while protecting social spending will support growth and an exit from fragility.

51. Staff welcome the authorities’ plan to unify the official and parallel ER market in the medium term, building on IMF CD. The choice between a gradual adjustment and an instant approach will ultimately be guided by FX buffers, financial sector vulnerabilities, and the choices of post-unification ER policy and monetary policy framework, as well as the political economy. Other supportive reforms, including tighter MP, FX market liberalization and growth-supportive reforms, will be required.

52. Considering ongoing inflationary pressures and rapid credit growth, the BRB should prepare to wind down the use of the special refinancing window with timely signaling to the market and recalibrate temporary measures. Winding down MP measures should be mindful of the large opportunity costs of prematurely withdrawing monetary policy accommodation, particularly as fiscal space is limited and increased liquidity injections and regulatory easing since 2020 have supported commercial banks’ health during the pandemic.

53. Boosting growth will require structural reforms to unlock growth bottlenecks, including addressing the roots of fragility and enhancing competitiveness and governance. Staff welcome ongoing reforms to support growth and reduce poverty and recommends accelerating the implementation of the PND reform agenda. Staff commends the authorities’ efforts to fast track the preparation of the budget review laws covering 2016–2021 to meet the CCRT’s commitment to finalize the 2020/21 report by March 2022. Staff is encouraged by the preparation of the first COVID-19 spending report in August 2021. Staff encourages collecting information on the ultimate beneficial ownership of companies that were awarded COVID-related contracts.

54. It is expected that the next Article IV consultation for Burundi will take place on the standard 12-month cycle.

Table 1.

Burundi: Selected Economic Indicators, 2019–27

article image
Sources; Burundi authorities; and IMF staff estimates and projections,

A statistical adjustment (15 percent) was applied to credit growth to account for the reclassification of a bank—the Urban Housing Promotion Fund became the Burundi Housing Bank in 2021 and is now covered in the monetary survey.

Fiscal year values (July-June) starting in 201 & (i.e. 201 & is FV 2018/19), Includes Covid-related fiscal measures starting in FV2020/21.

Includes vaccine donations (starting in FY2021/22) and the grant for the IMF debt service falling due from October 16, 2021 to April 13, 2022 under the CCRT, Starting with FY2025/23. grants also include project grants from the US and the EU, Grants averaged 17,7 percent of GDP per year during 5010–14, before the 2015 political crisis.

Table 2a.

Burundi: Central Government Operations, 2019–271

(BIF billion)

article image
Sources: Burundi authorities; and IMF staff estimates and projections.

Fiscal year values (July-June). Includes Covid-related fiscal measures starting in FY2020/21.

Sale of fixed capital assets included in nontax revenue rather than under expenditure.

Starting with FY2022/23, grants includes project grants from the US and the EU. Grants averaged 17.7 percent of GDP per year during 2010–14, before the 2015 political crisis. Projected World Bank grants account for most of projected grants during 2022–23 and about half of the grants during 2024–27. No World Bank grant is assumed after 2027.

Includes the grant for the IMF debt service falling due from October 16, 2021 to April 13, 2022, which is subject to the availability of resources under the CCRT.

Includes unforeseen spending and spending not properly classified due to lack of proper reconciliation between the Ministry in charge of Finance and the Central Bank. Covid spending envisaged in the FY2021/22 budget (BIF 70.4 billion or 1.07 percent of GDP) is not itemized in the budget but is included in some current and investment spending lines such as transfers to hospitals.

The strong increase in investment during FY2022/23 is due to a jump in domestic investment financed with part of the SDR allocation and project financing as per footnote 3.

A negative sign denotes a reduction of financial assets.

Staff projects that the central bank will on-lend in local currency to the government the equivalent of half of the SDR allocation in FY2022/23 (2.6 percent of GDP) and the remainder in FY2023/24 and FY2024/25.

Table 2b.

Burundi: Central Government Operations, 2019–271

(Percent of GDP)

article image
Sources: Burundi authorities; and IMF staff estimates and projections.

Fiscal year values (July-June). Includes Covid-related fiscal measures starting in FY2020/21.

Sale of fixed capital assets included in nontax revenue rather than under expenditure.

Starting with FY2022/23, grants includes project grants from the US and the EU. Grants averaged 17.7 percent of GDP per year during 2010–14, before the 2015 political crisis. Projected World Bank grants account for most of projected grants during 2022–23 and about half of the grants during 2024–27. No World Bank grant is assumed after 2027.

Includes the grant for the IMF debt service falling due from October 16, 2021 to April 13, 2022, which is subject to the availability of resources under the CCRT.

Includes unforeseen spending and spending not properly classified due to lack of proper reconciliation between the Ministry in charge of Finance and the Central Bank. Covid spending envisaged in the FY2021/22 budget (BIF 70.4 billion or about 1 percent of GDP) is not itemized in the budget but is included in some current and investment spending lines such as transfers to hospitals.

The strong increase in investment during FY2022/23 is due to a jump in domestic investment financed with part of the SDR allocation and project financing as per footnote 3.

A negative sign denotes a reduction of financial assets.

Staff projects that the central bank will on-lend in local currency to the government the equivalent of half of the SDR allocation in FY2022/23 (2.6 percent of GDP) and the remainder in FY2023/24 and FY2024/25.

Table 3.

Burundi: Monetary Survey, 2019–27

(BIF billion)

article image
Sources: Burundi authorities; IMF staff estimates and projections.

A statistical adjustment (15 percent) was applied to credit growth to account for the reclassification of a bank—the Urban Housing Promotion Fund became the Burundi Housing Bank in 2021 and is now covered in the monetary survey.

Table 4.

Burundi: Central Bank Accounts, 2019–27

(BIF billion)

article image
Sources: Burundi authorities; IMF staff estimates and projections.

Projections assuming that the unidentified BOP financing is filled.

Table 5a.

Burundi: Balance of Payments, 2019–27

(US$ Million)

article image
Sources: Burundi authorities; and IMF staff estimates and projections. 1 Based on preliminary information provided by donors. 2 Includes prospective IMF disbursements and CCRT grants. 3 Including trade credits and grants. BPM6 manual defines other investment as a residual category that includes all other changes in assets and liabilities of public and private sectors including trade credits and grants. 4 Includes recent SDR allocation as adviced in BPM6 manual.
Table 5b.

Burundi: Balance of Payments, 2019–27

(Percent of GDP)

article image
Sources; Burundi authorities; and IMF staff estimates and projections.

Based on preliminary information provided by donors.

Includes prospective IMF disbursements and CCRT grants.

Including trade credits and grants. BPM6 manual defines other investment as a residual category that includes all other changes in assets and liabilities of public and private sectors including trade credits and grants.

Table 6.

Burundi: Banking System Soundness Indicators, 2019–21

(Percent, unless otherwise indicated)

article image
Source; Burundi authorities.
Table 7.

Burundi: Indicators of Capacity to Repay the Fund, 2019–27

article image
Sources: IMF staff estimates and projections.

Total debt service includes IMF repurchases and repayments.

Table 8.

Burundi: Sustainable Development Indicators

article image
Source: World Bank Development Indicators

Annex I. The COVID-19 Pandemic and The Authorities’ Response

1. The pandemic: The first COVID-19 case in Burundi was reported on March 31, 2020. As of June 14, 2022, 42,330 cases and 15 deaths have been reported. New cases surpassed 1,000 cases per week in the second half of 2021, with a peak of more than 5,000 cases during the last week of December 2021 (up from an average of 20 cases per week in 2020 and an average of 371 cases per week during January-June 2021, see Figure A1.1). They are now down to about 446 cases per week since early 2022. Two large-scale testing campaigns were conducted during July 6–October 6, 2020, and January 11–February 11, 2021. The number of cases is likely underestimated as testing capacity remains weak with less than 3 percent of the population tested as of June 12, 2022 (Figure A1.2)

Figure A1.1.
Figure A1.1.

Burundi: New Confirmed COVID-19 Cases, 2020–22

(Daily Confirmed Cases, 7 Day Moving Average)

Citation: IMF Staff Country Reports 2022, 257; 10.5089/9798400219122.002.A001

Sources: Johns Hopkins University and IMF staff calculations.
Figure A1.2.
Figure A1.2.

Burundi: COVID-19 Cases and Testing

(Per 1 million population)

Citation: IMF Staff Country Reports 2022, 257; 10.5089/9798400219122.002.A001

Sources; Worldometers Reported COVID Data by Country, June 14, 2022

2. Government response:

  • Bujumbura airport was closed from March to November 2020. On January 11, 2021, the authorities closed land and sea borders to passengers, and imposed new restrictions to passengers arriving at the Bujumbura airport. In September 2021, the authorities introduced a fine of about US$ 50 for not wearing a mask in public places and public transportation in Bujumbura. The fine has been removed and masks are no longer mandatory.

  • The authorities developed a pandemic response plan — focusing on strengthening the health care system, the social safety net, and parts of the road network to facilitate access to sick people. The response plan was estimated at about US$ 150 million (4.5 percent of 2021 GDP), of which sanitary measures costing US$ 58 million (1.7 percent of 2021 GDP). The authorities have promoted preventative measures but have limited the use of social distancing to minimize adverse economic effects. They subsidized the price of soap during June-September 2020 and are subsidizing water for standpipes, up to 50 percent. They also hired additional doctors and nurses and have granted tax holidays to affected businesses.

  • As part of the response plan of 4.5 percent of GDP, the authorities spent 1.1 percent of GDP in 2020/21 (Text Table), including sanitary and non-sanitary measures. They plan to spend about 1 percent of GDP in 2021/22 (excluding vaccines). Staff estimates that a cumulated US$ 36.7 million (1.1 percent of GDP) has been spent on this plan at end-December 2021.

  • The central bank increased flexibility in loan restructuring with targeted and time-bound extensions of loan maturities to hard-hit borrowers. A new refinancing window has also been opened for banks extending long-term loans to high-growth priority sectors.

Text Table A1.1.

Burundi: COVID-19 Spending 1/

article image
Sources: Burundi authorities and IMF staff estimates.

Excludes spending on vaccination. Total Covid-related spending could be higher in reality but not separable from other budget lines due to data limitations.

For FY2D2D/21, it is spending up to February 2021.

3. Vaccination. Vaccination started at end-October 2021 with about 100 people vaccinated per day on average. Only 13,811 people (0.1 percent of the population) were fully vaccinated as of June 5, 2022. In 2021, Burundi received a donation of 500,000 doses of Sinopharm vaccine from China and a donation of 302,400 Johnson and Johnson vaccine doses through the African Vaccine Acquisition Trust (AVAT), which is expected to donate a total of 2.4 million doses of this vaccine to Burundi.

4. Urgent needs. Stronger diagnostic capacity is warranted (rapid testing and molecular analysis machines to identify variants of the virus), as well as better logistics (vehicles and the associated consumables and construction of travelers’ paths to reduce contamination) to contain imported cases and community transmission.

5. Donor support. So far, financial support has included a grant from the World Bank (US$5 million) and the fiscal space created by two years of IMF CCRT debt relief through April 2022 (SDR 17.96 million) and debt service relief from Exim Bank of China and the Kuwait Fund (US$ 0.93 million) under the G20 Debt Service Suspension Initiative (DSSI).

6. Governance. A technical committee for the response to the COVID-19 pandemic was set up. A single fiduciary fund, with an account opened at the BRB, was set up to centralize donor funding. The first COVID-19 report covering operations from the fiduciary fund was transmitted in August 2021 to the Court of Auditors, which started its audit in April 2022. The authorities emphasized that delays in auditing this COVID-19 report were due to a backlog of audits of government financial statements, which were only completed in mid-January 2022.

Annex II. External Sector Assessment

article image
article image
article image

Only the EBA-lite CA model was used in this analysis. EBA-lite REER approach has limitations when applied to countries with large structural changes or some data inconsistences. Additional to that, when CA and REER point to different conclusion, the CA model is often more informative and reliable (IMF, 2016).

Given the data issue on NIIP, the ESA for Burundi focuses on the current account EBA-lite method (see footnote 1 in the main text).

Annex III. Risk Assessment Matrix1

article image
article image
article image

Annex IV. Capacity Development Strategy

A. Capacity Development Strategy

1. Capacity Development (CD) for Burundi would focus in the near term on strengthening fiscal operations and policy design; supporting the transition to a unified exchange rate (ER), coherent ER policy, and efficient post-unification monetary policy framework; fostering financial sector stability; strengthening data transparency by implementing the enhanced General Data Dissemination System (e-GDDS); and improving data timeliness and quality, especially fiscal, external and national accounts statistics; and reducing corruption vulnerabilities and corresponding governance weaknesses. These areas are supported by the IMF’s surveillance and CD operations in Burundi. Priority areas would include:

  • i. Fiscal operations and policy design:

    • Revenue administration: strengthening of core functions and modernization, including through digitalization;

    • Tax policy: general review of the tax system, including mining taxation, to rationalize, enhance efficiency, and simplify while proposing areas to strengthen collection and widen the tax base;

    • Public finance management (PFM): strengthening of the budget process (preparation, formulation, execution, reporting and auditing); introduction of medium-term budgeting; and strengthening of the PFM framework to facilitate identification and follow up of pending bills and arrears; strengthening of public investment management, cash management and the operationalization of the Treasury Single Account (TSA); and strengthening of the macroeconomic projection model and fiscal risks analysis.

    • Expenditure policy: enhance spending composition and efficiency.

  • ii. Exchange rate policy:

    • Unification of the official and parallel exchange rates;

    • Transition to an appropriate post-unification ER policy and FX intervention policy;

    • FX market reform: liberalization, setting up an auctioning system.

  • iii. Monetary policy:

    • Transition to an appropriate post-unification monetary policy framework (MPF);

    • Strengthening monetary policy (MP) efficiency, including the design and use of standards MP instruments and elaborating a communication strategy;

    • Preparing for the Eastern African Community (EAC)’s medium-term goal of a price-based MPF.

  • iv. Financial sector stability:

    • Strengthening the supervisory frameworks (for banks and non-banks);

    • Regulatory framework: transition to new standards

  • v. Debt management:

    • Improving the quality of debt data;

    • Building capacity to undertake a comprehensive analysis of the existing debt portfolio in terms of cost and risk;

    • Enhancing debt monitoring and reporting;

    • Domestic market development and strengthening of cash management; and

    • Elaboration of a medium-term debt strategy addressing all relevant dimensions, including maturity, investor’s base, currency composition, cost optimization,

  • vi. Statistics: implementing the e-GDDS recommendations and publishing macroeconomic and financial data essential for surveillance and policy analysis through a National Summary Data Page (NSDP); improving the timeliness, quality, and coverage of

    • National accounts;

    • External sector statistics;

    • Government finance statistics and fiscal reporting;

    • Financial soundness indicators;

    • Monetary and financial statistics;

    • Debt statistics, including debt of publicly-owned enterprises, the local government, and the private sector, as well as the reporting of contingent liabilities.

  • vii. Governance:

    • Strengthening the Legal and Organizational Framework for addressing corruption based upon an identification of anticorruption priorities.

    • Improving the effectiveness of the AML/CFT framework in line with international standards.

B. Recent CD Activities

Revenue Administration

2. Recent CD missions have mainly been conducted from AFRITAC-Centre (AFC) and supported both customs and tax administrations.

3. CD missions on customs administration have aimed at strengthening its main functions, notably audit and control programs against smuggling, customs valuation procedures and risk-based controls procedures. Recent CD has been delivered through a regional seminar (January 2020), and standard CD missions (December 2019, October 2020, and November 2021). CD missions on tax administration have aimed at strengthening its main functions, notably the integrity of the tax base and the taxpayer registry, audit and control programs and the management of tax arrears. Support has also been given to strengthen and modernize the institutional management and governance framework of revenue administration. Recent CD has been delivered through a regional seminar (January 2020). A remote mission was also conducted during October-November 2020 to: (i) assess the impact of the measures taken to deal with the COVID-19 crisis; (ii) propose revenue safeguard measures; and (iii) support the digitization of procedures, including the implementation of innovative tools for reporting and payment of duties and taxes.

4. FAD and AFC a diagnostic mission, which was scheduled for April 28-May 17, 2022, was postponed to September 2022 at the authorities’ request. It will review all areas of fiscal reform (revenue administration, tax policy, public financial management, and debt management). FAD also plans to station a long-term fiscal expert in Burundi in the fall of 2022 to support the authorities’ fiscal reforms.

Tax Policy

5. No recent CD mission on tax policy has been conducted by the Fund. FAD is currently considering a diagnostic mission on the tax system at the authorities’ request. If approved, it could take place in FY2022/23.

Public Financial Management

6. Recent CD missions have mainly been conducted from AFC. Key objectives have been to: (i) improve budget preparation to make it more detailed, credible, and based on policies; (ii) strengthen the legal and institutional framework for public finances; (iii) strengthen identification, tracking and the management of fiscal risks; (iv) improve management of assets and liabilities; and (v) improve the coverage and quality of financial reports.

7. Recent CD has mainly been delivered through regional seminars (May, June, August and December 2019, February, and March 2020). A recent CD mission was conducted to support program budgeting (January 2022).

8. FAD and AFC are planning a diagnostic mission for April 28-May 17, 2022, at the authorities’ request.

Debt Management

9. A CD mission to strengthen public debt reporting practices is planned in FY2023. Financial supervision and stability

10. In recent years, the BRB has received several CD missions mostly pertaining to financial sector supervision and stability. These CD missions have mostly been conducted by AFC.

11. CD missions on financial stability aimed at strengthening BRB’s capacities in terms of financial supervision, risk and underlying vulnerabilities assessment and consistency of regulations with the Basel 3 framework.

12. The BRB is striving to upgrade its supervisory processes to move towards a risk-based supervision framework. In December 2020, a CD mission drafted a methodological guidance about on-site control of operational risk management frameworks. In March 2021, another mission drafted a methodological guidance about on-site control of the accounting function and the data-quality frameworks. More recently during March-April 2022, a CD mission focused on providing BRB supervisors the necessary tools in order to be able to perform risk based on-site inspections of banking institutions aimed at assessing the adequacy and effectiveness of their credit risk management frameworks. CD assistance has also been provided on IFRS 9 implementation to upgrade prudential requirements on credit classification and provisioning of expected credit losses (February 22 – March 19, 2021).

13. On the identification of underlying vulnerabilities in the financial sector front, the AFC conducted a CD mission over January to March 2022 aiming at developing a draft Internal Capital Adequacy Assessment Process (ICAAP) regulation and a methodological tool for BRB supervisors supporting the assessment of the ICAAP. This CD mission gave the opportunity to train the BRB’s supervisors on the Basel II Pillar 2 approach, the ICAAP framework and the stress testing guidelines.

Statistics

14. The most recent CD mission on National Accounts, took place in July 2021. The mission conducted by STA, provided technical assistance to the Institut des Statistiques et Etudes Economiques du Burundi (ISTEEBU). A GDP rebasing exercise is ongoing, benefiting from technical assistance from AFRISTAT and financial support from the World Bank. ISTEEBU is planning to publish the rebased GDP estimates for both 2016 (new base year) and 2017 by end-2022. During the July 2021 mission, the preliminary rebased GDP estimates for the new base year (2016), compliant with the System of National Accounts 2008 (2008 SNA), were reviewed and recommendations to improve the quality of the supply and use tables (SUT) were made. The mission trained ISTEEBU staff in backcasting to compile the 2005–2015 estimates.

15. Moreover, two CD missions on national accounts were conducted by AFC in October 2020 and May 2021, providing an opportunity to re-engage with the authorities, as the previous mission on this topic had taken place in 2017. The October 2020 technical assistance mission focused mainly on the use of the available data sources for the GDP rebasing exercise and the implementation of methodological recommendations of the 2008 SNA. AFC and STA have also provided limited technical assistance on GDP rebasing and provided important recommendations to improve the quality of the SUT for the new base year (2016). These include the treatment of the final household consumption expenditure, the informal sector estimates as well as changes to the trade margins. The May 2021 technical assistance mission focused on the improvement and further development of the quarterly national accounts. The authorities were also invited to regional workshops organized by AFC and by ATI in collaboration with STA.

16. TA on the CPI (and other price statistics) is provided by the East African Community. The most recent mission, October 18–November 05, 2021, assisted ISTEEBU with preparing to update CPI weights.

17. Over the last two years, Burundi has received a number of CD activities in Government finance statistics (GFS). GFS compilers from Burundi attended a regional AFC GFS webinar in April 19–23, 2021. This was followed by a GFS TA/training mission in June 14–25, 2021, to support the adoption of the GFSM2014 framework; and a GFS TA mission in January- February 2022 to facilitate implementation of the framework.

18. A remote mission to assist the authorities to implement the e-GDDS and publish data essential for surveillance through an NSDP took place in March/April 2022.

1

Limited imports, including fuel imports, in 2021Q4 owing to limited FX reserves led to fuel shortages and a ban of the use of cycles in Bujumbura from March 2022 led to public transportation disruptions.

2

While remittances include money transfers from 2019 (STA CD mission of January 2020), informal flows are unaccounted for. Origin countries include Canada, the U.S., Belgium, and Sweden.

3

The parallel market is informal and deemed illegal since 2019.

4

A statistical adjustment (15 percent) was applied to credit growth to account for the reclassification of a bank—the Urban Housing Promotion Fund became the Burundi Housing Bank in 2021 and is now covered in the monetary survey.

5

The baseline assumes vaccine donations (Annex I) to cover 21 percent of Burundians.

6

COVID-related spending is not itemized, see Tables 2a and 2b. Staff estimates that about US$ 42 million (1.3 percent of GDP) has been spent on the COVID response plan by end-December 2021.

7

Manufacturing production will be boosted by ongoing import substitution policies (cement and fertilizer factories) and stronger food and beverage production, supported by bank credit.

8

Several hydroelectric dams are in train, financed with European, Chinese and IDP funds and a World Bank solar project began in 2021 (combined cost of US$600 million). Three of these projects should start production by 2022 and three others during 2023–25. Power line and road projects are funded by the AfDB ($100 million).

9

A new financing agreement was signed with the U.S. (US$ 400 million over five years), reflecting the lifted sanctions.

10

Absent external shocks, inflation has been mostly driven by agricultural product supply. Inflation averaged 3 percent during 2015–20.

11

The authorities estimate trade credits, in the absence of recent enterprise, customs, and commercial bank surveys, and believe that the estimates are optimistic as operators might use other channels than swift (e.g., their FX accounts abroad), to circumvent FX shortages.

12

On March 29, 2022, an agreement was signed between the Ministry of Energy and the East African Projects Group for a nickel exploitation project, including equity deposit of US$ 500 million.

13

Burundi’s de jure exchange rate arrangement is floating, and its de facto exchange rate arrangement is crawl-like.

14

With an initial budgeted increase of 0.5 percent of GDP in 2021/22 (salary increase of previously discriminated civil servants).

15

In FY2020/21, capital spending represented 25 percent of total spending.

16

A bank can restructure a loan up to three times. A fourth restructuring requires the BRB’s agreement.

1

The Risk Assessment Matrix (RAM) shows events that could materially alter the baseline path. The relative likelihood is the staff’s subjective assessment of the risks surrounding the baseline (“low” is meant to indicate a probability below 10 percent, “medium” a probability between 10 and 30 percent, and “high” a probability between 30 and 50 percent). The RAM reflects staff views on the source of risks and overall level of concern as of the time of discussions with the authorities. Non-mutually exclusive risks may interact and materialize jointly. The conjunctural shocks and scenario highlight risks that may materialize over a shorter horizon (between 12 to 18 months) given the current baseline. Structural risks are those that are likely to remain salient over a longer horizon.

  • Collapse
  • Expand
Burundi: 2022 Article IV Consultation-Press Release; Staff Report; and Statement by the Executive Director for Burundi
Author:
International Monetary Fund. African Dept.