Romania
Report on Observance of Standards and Codes—Data Module

This Report on Observance of Standards and Codes analyzes the principal standard against which Romania's macroeconomic and sociodemographic data are assessed. With some exceptions, the statistics currently produced in Romania generally meet, and in most instances exceed, the recommendations of the General Data Dissemination System with respect to coverage, periodicity, and timeliness of dissemination. However, with respect to other aspects of quality, further improvements are needed, especially in national accounts and government finance statistics and, to a lesser extent, in other sectoral statistics.

Abstract

This Report on Observance of Standards and Codes analyzes the principal standard against which Romania's macroeconomic and sociodemographic data are assessed. With some exceptions, the statistics currently produced in Romania generally meet, and in most instances exceed, the recommendations of the General Data Dissemination System with respect to coverage, periodicity, and timeliness of dissemination. However, with respect to other aspects of quality, further improvements are needed, especially in national accounts and government finance statistics and, to a lesser extent, in other sectoral statistics.

I. The Standard 1

1. The principal standard against which Romania’s macroeconomic and socio-demographic data are assessed is the IMF’s General Data Dissemination System (GDDS).2 The GDDS emphasizes the development of core statistical frameworks and indicators, supplemented by encouraged extensions to core frameworks and indicators. In addition to the four sectors into which economic data are grouped (real, fiscal, financial, and external), the GDDS includes socio-demographic data.

2. The GDDS places emphasis on following sound practices in four dimensions:

  • the data dimension (the coverage, periodicity, and timeliness of the data)

  • quality of the disseminated data

  • integrity of the disseminated data

  • access by the public

3. The primary focus of the GDDS is on presenting a framework for evaluating the need for data improvements, prioritizing such improvements, and providing guidance on data dissemination. The GDDS also focuses on data quality, recognizing the fact that for many countries improvements in data quality are a necessary precursor to enhanced dissemination of data to the public. The GDDS provides clear links to the IMF’s Special Data Dissemination Standard (SDDS)—a more demanding standard for data dissemination—enabling a country to use the GDDS as a step towards subscription to the SDDS. Participation in the GDDS is voluntary. It requires a commitment to use the GDDS as a framework for statistical development; designation of a country coordinator; and preparation of metadata, for posting by the IMF on the Dissemination Standards Bulletin Board (DSBB).3

4. Romania participates in the GDDS and has made substantial progress in implementing its standards. A GDDS coordinator has been appointed, and metadata, including plans for improvement, have been posted on the DSBB. The authorities have been encouraged to make the metadata available domestically and have indicated their intention to subscribe to the Special Data Dissemination Standard (SDDS) as conditions permit.

II. Summary of Practices

5. The coverage, periodicity, and timeliness for macroeconomic data in Romania are summarized and contrasted with GDDS recommendations in Table 1. As regards the quality of data, an experimental framework identifying six key aspects by which to assess the data is presented in Box 1 and is applied in Table 2.4

Table 1.

Romania: Data Categories and Indicators: Comparison of the GDDS Recommendations and National Practices

(* Indicates SDDS standard is met)

article image
article image
article image
article image
article image
article image

As proposed by Mr. Marian Mustāreatā, Director, Statistics Division. [Note added by NBR.]

With respect to reference data or end of reference period.

Dissemination as part of a high-frequency (e.g. monthly) publication.

All indicators should be classified as applicable by age, gender, urban/rural residence and/or relevant attributes.

The World Bank, in collaboration with other international institutions, is developing a set of recommended good practices.

Table 2

Romania: Salient Features of the Data Quality Matrix

article image
article image
article image
article image
article image
article image

A. Data Dimension: Coverage, Periodicity, and Timeliness

Real sector

6. National accounts are compiled by the National Institute of Statistics and Economic Studies (NISES). These data meet the GDDS recommendations, and are quite close to satisfying the stricter disclosure requirements of the SDDS. GDP data, at current and constant prices, are produced quarterly and published within three months of the end of the reference period. Currently, the quarterly constant price figures are measured at the prices of the same quarter of the previous year. However, a system based on internationally recommended chain-linked indices is being developed. A full set of sector accounts are also produced annually, except for balance sheets, which are planned to be constructed within the next year. The accounts generally conform to the concepts of the European System of Accounts 1995 (1995 ESA), though adjustments are required to bring the data for past years into line. Coverage of informal activities is mainly based on the Labor Force Survey (LFS), which is a conceptually sound approach, and specific adjustments are also made for activities believed not to be covered by the LFS. In common with the vast majority of other countries, estimates are not made for illegal activities, due to the extreme difficulty in establishing reasonable sources and methods for these activities.

7. Substantial quarterly revisions to GDP estimates result from the reconciliation of quarterly with annual data. A major reason for this is that the NISES introduces revisions to quarterly data only once a year at the time of the annual reconciliation even though the nature and extent of some revisions are known ahead of the annual cycle.

8. The consumer price index (CPI) conforms to the requirements of the GDDS as well as the SDDS in terms of periodicity and timeliness. Though principally based on prices collected in urban areas, national data from peasant markets and utility services are also covered. The weights used in aggregating the index are based on national data collected through the household integrated5 survey; the weights are updated every year beginning in 1999. The producer price index (PPI) also meets the requirements of the GDDS and SDDS in terms of periodicity and timeliness. Currently, it only measures changes in domestic prices, but exports will be included shortly, covering all periods. A program has been introduced to update the PPI weights every three years.

9. A monthly volume index of industrial production is constructed, covering all production industries. A full range of labor statistics is also produced, in concordance with the requirements of the GDDS and SDDS.

Fiscal sector

10. Fiscal data compiled by the Ministry of Finance (MOF) and disseminated in its publications and on its website (www.mfinance.ro) are the most problematic of the four economic sectors in terms of meeting GDDS recommendations on coverage. While the periodicity and timeliness of these data meet GDDS recommendations, the coverage does not. In both the monthly and annual data disseminated to the public, data on government grants are not available, and more importantly, the existence of several significant extrabudgetary accounts on which comprehensive information is not made available to the public, makes it difficult to obtain a comprehensive understanding of government operations. In this context, the failure to disseminate data on the financing of the overall fiscal balance makes it impossible to verify the consistency of data on government financial operations with other sectoral financial data, and clouds the user’s ability to ascertain which fiscal activities are covered in the accounts. A well-articulated and time-bound action plan has not yet been developed to improve the quality and public dissemination of fiscal data, but the MOF has begun work on an accrual set of accounts in anticipation of the proposed changes in the IMF’s Government Finance Statistics Manual.

11. Data on central government and publicly guaranteed debt are compiled by the MOF on a monthly basis and disseminated through MOF publications and its website, usually within a few days of the end of the preceding month in the case of government debt and three weeks for guaranteed debt.

Financial sector

12. Financial sector statistics are compiled by the National Bank of Romania (NBR). The data for the banking system meet GDDS recommendations and almost all series additionally meet SDDS standards on coverage, periodicity, and timeliness. The only exception in timeliness is for reserve money in the Central Bank aggregates (Analytical Accounts of the Central Bank in the SDDS), which is only delayed by a matter of days. The definitions used by the NBR, with the exceptions noted below, are generally consistent with the IMF’s Monetary and Financial Statistics Manual (MFSM) and the residency criteria recommended in the IMF’s Balance of Payments Manual, fifth edition (BPM5).

13. The NBR adopted accrual accounting as part of the introduction of a new chart of accounts (Chart of Accounts and Methodological Norms of Law number 101/1998, an amendment to the National Bank of Romania Act). However, NBR’s holdings of treasury bills and government bonds and loans extended by the NBR and the commercial banks continue to be recorded on a cash basis.6 Furthermore, accrued interest is included in other assets, rather than being recorded with the underlying instrument, as recommended by the MFSM.

14. Also, in contrast to MFSM and BPM5 residency recommendations, NBR’s foreign assets exclude Romania’s membership subscriptions in international organizations, including Romania’s IMF quota and subscriptions to the World Bank, European Bank for Reconstruction and Development, Bank for International Settlements, International Financial Corporation, and the Multilateral Investment Guarantee Agency, which are classified as domestic assets. Similarly, deposits of these organizations, including the IMF deposits that correspond to the IMF quota, are classified as domestic liabilities.

External sector

15. Balance of payments data generally meet GDDS recommendations and SDDS standards on periodicity and timeliness, and also meet them for coverage of most components. The NBR does not publish a debt service schedule as recommended in the GDDS, but is taking steps to add a debt service schedule to the list of indicators disseminated.

Social and demographic indicators

20. The NISES compiles and disseminates indicators on population, education, health, and poverty that meet GDDS objectives for coverage, periodicity, and timeliness. Population data from the census are updated during inter-censal years by using data derived from administrative records on births, deaths, and migration. The next census will be held in 2002.

21. The NISES calculates a broad set of health indices based on data received from the County Public Health Directorates, ministries that have their own medical network, the Ministry of Labor and Social Protection, the Ministry of Finance, and the National House of Health Insurance. Data on education are derived from educational units of all levels, and expenditure figures related to education are available from the Ministry of Finance. The classification system conforms to the International Standard Classification of Education (ISCED).

22. Poverty indices are derived from data collected through the Integrated Household Survey (IHS), a permanent multifunctional statistical survey, performed on a sample of 36,000 households, in 501 counties throughout the country. The information collected through this questionnaire covers members of the household (age, sex, education level, and occupational status); household consumption, expenses, and incomes; living conditions and ownership of durable goods.

B. Data Quality, Integrity, and Access

Statistical framework

23. Three agencies are primarily responsible for the production and dissemination of data covered by the GDDS—the NISES, MOF, and the NBR. The dissemination of most data is carried out as a public service. All three agencies currently disseminate data through various publications and the internet.

24. The role and responsibilities of the NISES are covered by an Ordinance on Statistics, last updated in September 2000. The president of the NISES is appointed, and reports to, the Prime Minister. Under the provisions of the Ordinance, the NISES is responsible for producing and disseminating objective and reliable statistical information, and for providing all users with equal access to these data. The Ordinance sets out the rights and obligations of respondents to statistical inquiries. It also guarantees the confidentiality of reported data and provides for administrative sanctions in cases of a breach of these requirements.

25. The MOF is responsible for compiling and disseminating fiscal data, including that for central and local government operations and the social security budget, and central government and government-guaranteed debt. The Budget Law of Romania authorizes the MOF to collect the information from local governments and government agencies to prepare statistics on government operations as needed for budgetary purposes. The annual report on the implementation of the central government budget is submitted to Parliament at the end of the fiscal year on the occasion of the presentation of the next year’s budget. The Law requires the Treasury Department of the MOF to consolidate the reports on the implementation of the local and central government budgets. The MOF provides these consolidated reports to the parliament, government agencies, and other official users, and the IMF Government Finance Statistics Yearbook. In addition, annual and monthly aggregated data for the central and local government and the Social Security Fund are disseminated on the MOF website and in NBR and NISES publications.

26. The NBR is responsible for producing and disseminating data on the financial and external sectors. These data are produced and disseminated in accordance with requirements of (a) NBR’s charter as outlined in the Banking Act (Law number 58/1998); (b) the National Bank of Romania Act (Law number 101/1998), (c) the Chart of Accounts and the Methodological Norms specifying the use of the NBR’s accounts; (d) the Foreign Exchange Regulation Number 3/1997, and, (e) guidelines of the Ministry of Finance on actions for closing the financial year.

27. The provisions in these laws and regulations grant the NBR the legal right to require the submission of information by banks, financial companies, and institutions. They also require that the NBR ensure the confidentiality of all information it gathers. Severe penalties are specified for failure to treat data confidentially. The dissemination of statistical data is mandated by the National Bank of Romania Act. The NBR, as a result, has undertaken an extensive dissemination program. The program includes dissemination of monthly and annual data through publications, press releases, and posting of most recent data on the NBR web site (http://www.bnro.ro).

28. The NISES is responsible for the production and dissemination of socio-demographic data. The broad legal authority of the NISES noted in paragraph 20 allows the NISES to develop reliable statistics based on direct collection of data supplemented by data from administrative records.

Source data

29. According to the Ordinance on Statistics, all institutions of the public sector (general government and government enterprises) as well as private enterprises, self-employed persons, households and individuals must report statistical information to the NISES. The Ordinance sets out the range and type of official statistics to be compiled. The NISES is charged with the responsibility for developing and ensuring the implementation of the statistical standards, classifications, and methodology for collecting, compiling and disseminating these data. Accordingly, the NISES designs and runs surveys for the collection of statistical data. However, much of these data are compiled from administrative records of the MOF, including that for enterprises.

30. Data on government revenues and expenditures, covering all government levels, are compiled from administrative records of the MOF’s Treasury Department, as supplemented by submissions from government ministries and agencies. Data on expenditures on development projects financed through grants and loans from abroad are incomplete but recorded in the treasury accounts as they are provided. Domestic and foreign debt data are provided by the General Department of Public Debt at the MOF.

31. The monetary aggregates published by the NBR are based on actual accounting records of the NBR and the other depository corporations. Separate balance sheet data for the monetary authorities and for other depository corporations are published by the NBR.

32. The NBR relies primarily on reports from commercial banks on their own transactions and customer transactions, direct reporting by official agencies and international organizations for the compilation of the balance of payments.

33. There are several weaknesses in the source data used to compile external sector data. The most significant relates to the measurement of foreign direct investment income and related financial account transactions, which is due to the reliance on the international transactions reporting system (ITRS). The NBR is in the process of introducing a survey of foreign direct investors so that it can produce more accurate data for these transactions.

34. In addition, the NBR will be upgrading the ITRS program by introducing new reporting forms for clients of commercial banks on their nonresident receipts and payments. Under the new system, to be introduced next year, the commercial banks will report to the NBR all transactions between residents and nonresidents on a transaction by transaction basis, improving the accuracy and coverage of BOP data other than foreign direct investments, particularly transfers and other nontrade current account items.

35. The NBR compiles an international investment position (IIP) statement, which is disseminated annually, with selected data items published monthly. The sources of data are the same as those for the relevant portions of the BOP statement. The IIP statement, therefore, has similar deficiencies particularly with respect to the measurement of foreign direct investments, and the planned improvements in the BOP source data will also lead to improvements in the IIP statement.

36. The compilation of socio-demographic data by the NISES is based on the decennial census for population, vital statistics system, the Integrated Household Survey for poverty, surveys on labour force and salaries, etc., reporting from other government units for health, and direct reporting from schools for education.

Statistical techniques

37. Substantial quarterly revisions to GDP estimates result from the reconciliation of quarterly with annual data. A major reason for this is that the NISES introduces revisions to quarterly data only once a year at the time of the annual reconciliation even though the nature and extent of some revisions are known ahead of the annual cycle.

38. These reconciliations relate to eliminating differences in measures of GDP (production, expenditure, and income approaches), differences between quarterly and annual estimates, and differences among institutional sector accounts. No adjustments are made for seasonality, but adjustments have to be applied to the collected data for the national accounts to cover underreporting. Additions are also made for those producers not covered in the registered statistics. The fact that national accounts data are often subject to massive revisions raises concerns with respect to the accuracy of the data. GDP components in particular for quarterly GDP data, are occasionally not very plausible.

39. The MOF does not make any statistical or seasonal adjustments to the fiscal data it compiles, which are provided both on a monthly and annual format. Receipts and payments in foreign currency are transacted through the NBR at the prevailing market exchange rate on the date the transaction is effected.

40. The NBR does not use any sampling or other estimating techniques for monetary statistics. Statistical and seasonal adjustment are also not used. For the balance of payments, the NBR and the NISES make coverage adjustments to the customs data. Otherwise, the BOP is compiled on the basis of the international transactions reporting system (ITRS), which reflects cash transactions through the commercial banks, supplemented by information from the MOF and the NBR’s own records. The BOP data are not adjusted for seasonality. The NBR also produces and disseminates an annual international investment position statement (IIP). The IIP uses the same sources of data as the BOP and therefore has similar limitations.

41. The NISES relies on censuses and surveys in the compilation and dissemination of socio-demographic data. The surveys are conducted in accordance with recommendations for development of sampling frames. Censuses are subject to post-enumeration survey analyses.

Serviceability

42. The NISES publishes brief descriptions of concepts and methods in each issue of the Monthly Statistical Bulletin and the Statistical Yearbook. A more detailed description was produced a few years ago, with the assistance of the OECD, but this has not yet been updated. Data series are published in sufficient detail to allow users to make rough cross-checks in order to validate the estimates.

43. Government finance data depart significantly from internationally accepted recommendations, particularly with respect to financing data. No comprehensive documentation of the methodology applied is disseminated by the MOF, but footnotes to individual tables provide some guidance to classification standards. Data on the general government operations are disseminated with some classification details which permit limited reasonability checks by the users. However, as no data on the financing of the overall balance are disseminated, it is impossible to cross-check the fiscal and the money and banking data. The MOF has recently begun work to reconcile MOF data on bank financing and the NBR data on the banking sector’s net claims on government.

44. With regard to the provision of information that allows users to assess aspects of the quality of data, the NBR provides footnotes and methodological notes to the monetary and balance of payments tables published in its Monthly Bulletin and Annual Report. In addition, the NBR publishes a Balance of Payments and International Investment Report that provides a detailed methodology for the external sector. There are no other published methodologies, although the NBR has provided comprehensive notes on balance of payments compilation to the IMF for inclusion in the Balance of Payments Yearbook. The data disseminated by the NBR are presented in sufficient component detail and time series to permit users to assess the reasonableness of data.

45. The monetary survey data produced by the NBR uses balance sheets from its own accounts and from monthly balance sheet reports submitted by the other depository corporations. The BOP relies on the balance sheet data from the monetary survey for some financial account transactions, thus ensuring a degree of similarity of instrument and institutional coverage. The BOP data on reserves are checked for consistency with the foreign asset position of the banking system. The NBR uses the BPM5 residency criterion for both the monetary survey and the BOP, although in practice the residency rule is not applied uniformly.7

46. There are plans to strengthen data compilation at the NBR and at agencies that provide data to it. For its part, the NBR is currently reviewing the compilation of monetary statistics in light of the IMF’s Manual on Monetary and Financial Statistics (MFSM) and has also embarked on a program to improve the analytical framework for international reserves, exchange rates, and interest rates. In the balance of payments area, the NBR has undertaken a broad program to improve data compilation through the: (a) introduction a foreign direct investment survey that will improve estimates of current and financial transactions of foreign direct investors, and (b) introduction of an expanded program to collect data from the commercial banks on customers’ transactions. Finally, the MOF will begin to compile data on grant aid through an upgrade of the DMFAS program that will distinguish between current and capital transfers.

47. Social and demographic data are disseminated in sufficient component detail and time series format to permit users to assess the reasonableness of these data. A post-enumeration survey is conducted to verify coverage of the census. However, discrepancies between administrative and survey data are not reconciled, leading to differences in disseminated data.

Accessibility

48. The NISES does not currently publish an advance release calendar, but is planning to do so within the next 12 months. All data, including socio-demographic data, are released simultaneously to all users through press releases, regular publications and the Internet.

49. The MOF disseminates statistics simultaneously to all users outside the ministry through its own publications and its website (www.mfinante.ro). These data include information on central and local government revenues and expenditures, and are supplemented by the operations of several extrabudgetary accounts including the Social Security Fund. While the MOF does not produce an advance release calendar, data are provided on a regular basis.

50. The NBR does not provide a methodology for the compilation of monetary statistics. However, disseminated data broadly conform to the guidelines of the IMF’s MFSM, and the NBR provides some methodological notes in its Annual Report. Data are published in the Monthly Bulletin and the Annual Report and are available on the NBR’s web site (http://www.bnro.ro). A methodology for the compilation of the balance of payments and the international investment position is published and updated annually in the NBR’s Balance of Payments and International Investment Position.

51. NBR data are released simultaneously to all users. Data are provided to the Ministry of Finance, international organizations and the Parliament ahead of release to the general public. Commentaries and analyses are provided for some data series (the monetary survey and the balance of payments) at the time of the release of the data.

52. Social and demographic data are disseminated in sufficient component detail and time series format to permit users to assess reasonableness of data. Publications containing relevant data contain technical notes explaining the concepts and definitions used. The NISES usually conducts a post enumeration survey for major statistical events.

III. IMF Staff Commentary

53. Romania’s transition to a market economy necessitated dramatic changes in its statistical system. With extensive external technical assistance, including some from the Fund, as well as under the impetus of economic adjustment programs, the authorities have embarked on a program of implementing new, internationally recognized statistical methodologies and establishing a framework for monitoring macroeconomic developments. The NISES, MOF, and NBR have enhanced their capability to compile and disseminate statistics to meet the needs of both official and private users of statistics. Substantial improvements have been made in all statistical areas.

54. With some exceptions, the statistics currently produced in Romania generally meet, and in most instances exceed, the recommendations of the GDDS with respect to coverage, periodicity and timeliness of dissemination. However, with respect to other aspects of quality, further improvements are needed, especially in national accounts and government finance statistics and, to a lesser extent, in other sectoral statistics.

55. Three characteristics of the fiscal sector accounts particularly hamper the interpretation of central government budgetary operations. First, of particular concern is the practice of not disseminating data on government budgetary financing. In the absence of data on budgetary financing items the normal cross-checks to verify the budgetary deficit levels are not available, reducing confidence in the comprehensiveness of budget data. Second, the growing practice of moving important policy initiatives off-budget makes the reconciliation of financing flows and debt stocks particularly important. In particular, the agency which purchases nonperforming loans from the banking sector, known by the Romanian acronym of AVAB, was moved off-budget in January 2000, but continues to be funded by government debt as it purchases nonperforming loans from the banking sector at face value. Third, the distinction between government debt and publicly guaranteed debt is not as clear as it is in most countries, with the government issuing guarantees for energy-related government agency operations that are important elements of public policy. Greater political commitment to fiscal transparency will be required to resolve these issues.

56. Real sector statistics fully conform to the requirements of the GDDS for periodicity and coverage, but not for timeliness. Discrepancies related to the reconciliation between quarterly GDP data and annual GDP data have limited the ability of analysts to use these data with confidence. The problem is particularly acute in respect to the growth rates of quarterly GDP components, some of which are not plausible, and in some cases they are not compatible with the annual data.

57. Many deficiencies in national accounts data can be traced either directly or indirectly to the shortage of skilled staff. Low wage scales are a chronic problem endemic to all government agencies, and in the absence of any other funds to supplement these wages, it is extremely difficult for the NISES and other government data reporting agencies to attract and retain the suitably qualified staff necessary to perform their mission. This not only jeopardizes the planned improvements to statistics, but also risks a deterioration in the quality of the existing systems.

58. Financial and external sector statistics produced and disseminated by the NBR generally conform to GDDS recommendations. Existing areas of concern, such as the misapplication residency standards to certain foreign assets, the lack of adherence to accrual accounting principles, and deficiencies in the measurement of foreign direct investment, and nontrade current account items, particularly transfers, are likely to be eliminated through ongoing programs given the strong commitment to the development of reliable statistics by management and the presence of a devoted and well-trained staff.

59. The NISES has developed accurate measures for socio-demographic data (population, labour market, education, health, and poverty), and remains alert to the need for continued review and improvement. The greatest need is to address issues relating to the harmonization of the compilation of current data with EUROSTAT standards, a process that is currently underway.

60. Romania’s participation in the GDDS should provide a new stimulus to the process of transforming its statistical system. As part of their efforts at meeting the recommendations of the GDDS, the authorities have articulated comprehensive plans for improvement in their data compilation and dissemination practices, including prioritization, sequencing, and timing of implementation. The work program to improve the quality of statistics is detailed and is available on the DSBB at http://dsbb.imf.org/. Many of the initiatives run through to the medium term and beyond, and the special emphasis on meeting EUROSTAT standards should encourage a substantial improvement in the quality of data.

61. The program of future improvements undertaken by the authorities represents a credible first step toward their stated objective of subscribing to the SDDS in the medium term. Final achievement of this objective, however, will require the commitment of additional resources, both physical and financial, to the compilation and dissemination of statistical data.

IV. Comments from the Authorities

62. The Romanian authorities did not make any substantive comments on the report. A number of technical changes were suggested, all of which have been included in this paper.

An Approach to the Assessment of Data Quality

article image
1

In preparing this report, the staff held discussions with officials in the National Institute of Statistics and Economic Studies, National Bank of Romania, and the Ministry of Finance.

2

Guides to the IMF’s General Data Dissemination System and the Special Data Dissemination Standard (SDDS) can be found on the IMF’s Dissemination Standards Bulletin Board on the Internet at http://dsbb.imf.org.

3

Metadata refers to information about the data, such as how data are compiled and disseminated, data coverage, periodicity, timeliness, and plans for improvement.

4

This framework, which draws upon work done in the Fund and in other organizations, especially national statistical offices, focuses on six areas vital to the production and dissemination of statistics. These areas are the statistical infrastructure, including the legal and material basis for data production; the conceptual framework; the nature and characteristics of the source data, the statistical techniques used to compile the data; the serviceability or usefulness of the data compiled; and the accessibility of the data and metadata.

5

Module of the Family Budget.

6

It should be noted that the NBR’s financial summary balance sheet, prepared once a year, incorporates full accrual accounting principles. The financial statement is published in the NBR’s Annual Report, but it does not provide sufficient detail for analysis.

7

The major divergence from the internationally accepted residency rule concerns accounts of international organizations, which are treated as domestic assets and liabilities.